Source: ShowbizSpy | Posted By: Dan Geer

David_Duchovny

We all know David Duchovny is a strong supporter of a third X-Files film. He has repeatedly said in many interviews over the last couple of years that, even though the last film wasn’t as successful as they had hoped, he is game for a third film.

But how about releasing it in the summertime, like they did with The X-Files: I Want to Believe? Would that be wise on the part of 20th Century Fox? Duchovny seems to think so. Read on for an excerpt from his interview with ShowbizSpy on the matter!

Regarding making The X-Files 3 a success, Duchovny says (from ShowbizSpy):

“It’s just a matter of spending enough on a movie that can compete in the summertime. We made a movie and released it in the summer, but it wasn’t really a blockbuster movie. And it got kind of overshadowed by the bigger ones. So, we’re saying, make us big. We’ll fight with the big boys.”

Now, while I agree that the third film would naturally need a bigger budget if it is still to be about the 2012 alien colonization plot that was so well-established in the TV series and first feature film, I am not so sure releasing it in the summertime is the wisest move – even though the story may seem more fitting for a summertime release.

To me, releasing it then would simply cause the film to get lost in the mix, hurting it’s take at the box office. I Want to Believe basically went head-to-head with The Dark Knight in the summer of ’08 and all but lost financially. Making the third film a summertime movie would mean that, since the story would take place in 2012, it would have to be released next summer – putting it up against the third “Batman” film, The Dark Knight Rises, as well as other major blockbusters coming out that same summer. Even if the story is bigger and better the third time around, this still seems like an awfully big risk.

While I am an X-Files nut, I know that other “fanboy” films will get more attention if the movie is released in the summer – especially since I Want to Believe was critically panned and not well-received by the general movie-going public. I think that, even with a bigger budget and a more entertaining plot, the film should still come out a bit later in the year, like in September or October when most the biggies have already come and gone. Typically, many comedies and dramas come out then, which would really make XF3 stand out and give sci-fi junkies something to see when nothing else is coming out that fits the “genre” bill. It would all but eliminate the competition, giving the film a better chance to shine.

In the end, the promotion of The X-Files 3 needs to be much better than the last time around. Aside from the need for showing better trailers further in advance (and more often), the film needs to be released at the right time. I think next year is the right time. Next summer, however, is not.

But hey, at least the cast and crew, including Duchovny, still all want to do the film. Now, it’s up to FOX (and I don’t mean Mulder).

Head on over to ShowbizSpy for the rest of the article.

Related Articles

  • dangeer

     No X-Files 3 for 2012, but XF Producer Frank Spontiz says a movie still could happen, even after this year. Nothing is officially confirmed. I don’t think 20th Century Fox is interested quite yet.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=787046143 Cheryl Mich

    Is X-files 3 coming out? I really would be interested!

  • http://yahoo June Desselle

    want a x file movie no matter what when where start the movie please!

  • Nardz-(X-file fan that counts)

    Im fully behind a third movie and even more episodes..do it till you cant is how I feel..please…im watching Fringe now…its cool…its just not NEARLY as good…honestly..the only reason im even watching it is to fulfill my craving for more Xfiles. And its a terrible substitute, where the hell is all the cool stuff what about some aliens? its practically always about some virus or some chemical that makes you fall apart or explode into pieces or something boring like that..I mean come one..friggin lame..”Olivia Dunham” im sorry…very annoying…stuck up, cocky, attitude to her authorities and they do nothing about it, she goes on intuition mostly instead of finding out the facts…shes not consistent at all…one minute shes a sweet heart with feelings and emotions, the next scene shes a hard ass jumping off 2 story buildings to chase bad guys…can you say Bipolar and super fake? Xfiles had better science, physics, plots/stories, jokes, everything..Please bring back X-files…and to all you fools who are like change actors and director…SO STUPID! it wouldn’t be the Xfiles then and you dumbasses arn’t real fans. Id watch David and Gillian play those characters till they were like 70 years old!

  • Mr. X.

    I want another X-Files movie with Gillian and David! Obviously, with Carter at the helm.

  • http://www.popcornmonster.com Dan Geer

    I’d love to see a reboot of the series someday. But I still feel there is at least one good mythology story to tell about aliens colonizing (or trying to colonize) the earth in 2012. Duchovny and Anderson are both still a good age to play the characters, and it would be nice to see some closure.

    I had a difficult time liking XF2 at first. While I knew it would be a stand-alone movie not connected to the mythology, it wasn’t very theatrical to me. However, while watching it on the small screen, I realized that the film plays out much better since it feels more like a random, albeit extended stand-alone episode of the series.

  • Doug Loyd

    I have been a fan of The X-Files show for many years and nothing brings me greater joy than hearing Gillian Anderson uttering the line “Mulder?…” BUT, and it’s a big BUT, XF2 was a train wreck of a movie. It was, in my humble opinion, very poorly executed.

    I seriously wish the producers and stars of the show would consider “rebooting” the series on an HBO or Showtime type network with a scaled back episode quota. (Think Dexter with only 10 episodes a season.) Now wouldn’t THAT be fantastic?

  • http://www.popcornmonster.com Dan Geer

    brunoman17,

    While I agree that the show wasn’t as good in its later years, and that perhaps the show didn’t need to continue for as long as it did, I still feel it was better than anything else on TV at the time. In fact, I think Season 8 had some of the greatest episodes of the series. I guess I enjoyed many things about those later seasons that you just didn’t find appealing. To each his own, I guess. I certainly would’ve rather been watching X-Files at the time than anything else. Even today, I’d still rather watch the show’s later seasons than, say, V or Fringe (and I like those shows). I also think the audience all but left because Mulder wasn’t as present and they weren’t willing to give new, different main cast members a chance. Mulder was the show in the minds of most fans. But for me, his “presence” was still felt, which is why I thought the show was still good, if not great. I am, however, very happy the show did not continue after Season 9.

    Also, alien colonization was pretty much a part of the storyline from the get-go. The end of the Mayan Calendar was just a logical place for the event to take place. In fact, there was an episode early on in the series where the Syndicate is discussing the event and how they’re “fifteen years away” from that. I’m pretty sure that, when that episode aired, it was roughly fifteen years away from 2012.

    I’m not real clear on Carter’s initial plan for the show, but I seem to recall pressure from FOX that the show should continue beyond five or six years because of how successful it was. Not sure how much control he had over the situation, but I can understand the decision either way.

    You’re right about the “legal limbo” status of The X-Files being made into a second feature film, although I don’t think people “forgot” about The X-Files. People just needed to be reminded of just how good the show was. I still hold that, between a combination of poor promotion of IWTB and the “wake” of The Dark Knight, either not enough people knew about it or movie-goers just preferred to see The Dark Knight. Remember, TDK was HUGE the first weekend, and many who didn’t see it the first weekend saw it the following weekend instead to try and avoid the crowds and long lines. Guess what other movie was being released that weekend? The X-Files: I Want to Believe. Of course, the crowds and lines for The Dark Knight went beyond the opening weekend and proceeded to form weekend after weekend after weekend. You have to admit that one week after TDK was not a good time for anything to come out.

    The Dark Knight was the biggest release at the time, it was heavily promoted and people were curious about Heath Ledger’s last major performance. It made over $533 million – domestically! Even for a blockbuster-type film, this amount of money is unusual. Sure, there were probably some who read reviews of The X-Files, and yes many reviews were poor. However, by that time people already had their minds made up to see The Dark Knight whether they read the reviews or not. But that doesn’t mean they wouldn’t have wanted to see a good X-Files film some other time.

    I stand by what I said in my previous post as well as this one: Poor promotion, poor timing. I can’t tell you how many times I ran into people not even aware IWTB was out until after I had mentioned it to them. The promotion of The Dark Knight was rampant, and the promotion of I Want to Believe was virtually non-existent. It should’ve done better, and would have if it more people knew about it, and it were released a few weeks later. Having said that, for being a smaller, stand-alone story six years after the show’s end, IWTB still made over $68 million worldwide, which is over twice its budget. The film underperformed, but it was still successful. It put up a good fight, despite the odds it was up against.

    Any movie coming out only one week after The Dark Knight was destined to underperform. Nothing did great that weekend. Will Ferrell’s movie Step Brothers did fairly well, even better than IWTB. But again, it was promoted better and it didn’t beat The Dark Knight. Not even close. Also, comedies with marketable actors prove to be good competition against sci-fi, action and fantasy movies because they’re extreme alternatives with a different audience in mind.

    Bottom line is, the “Batman” franchise in general has a bigger fanbase and a more wide appeal than The X-Files. It has an easier time being a story that pretty much stands on its own. The only way The X-Files 3 stands a chance is to “look like” the only good thing out in theaters, which requires a later, fall release when not much else is out.

    Like I said in my first reply to you, I have to agree to disagree. I liked IWTB, you didn’t. But I think it is undeniable that The Dark Knight was a box office juggernaut, and releasing anything only one week after was simply folly. Nothing could compete, good or bad.

    Lastly, as a fan I’m open to a reboot, but only after Duchovny and Anderson sing their last swan song with XF3 to conclude the alien mythology. Duchovny and Anderson ARE Mulder and Scully in the public eye, and they do hold box office clout if its an X-Files film concluding the mythology. That’s how iconic those characters are, and I’m pretty sure FOX knows this. After XF3, wait ten years and reboot all you like. People will accept it then.

    P.S.: Don’t worry about your long rants. As you can see, I’m guilty as well. :)

  • brunoman17

    Believe it or not I’m a big fan of the X-Files. I remember watching the show on Friday’s in September 1993, then moved to Sunday’s in 1996 “Unruhe” was the first Sunday episode if I recall, but the TV show ended on a bitter note. I wish Chris Carter stuck to his original plan and make the TV show for five years then concentrate on the movie series, but that never happened. Instead the TV show limped on for another four years with silly storylines like Scully’s miracle baby, Mulder coming back from the dead, alien super soldiers terminators, and the alien invasion of 2012. By the time the series finale aired, the core audience pretty much left the show and The X-Files finale went out with a wimper. Then the X-Files was mired in legal limbo for years, by the time those issues got resolved, almost all of the general audience has forgotten about the X-Files. Now Chris Carter had a chance to redeem himself with all the mistakes he made during the last years of the show, by making a good, scary, and suspenseful X-Files movie. He failed on all counts, and that’s why I don’t have any confidence in him and Frank Spotnitz to make another good X-Files movie. Blaming the Dark Knight is just another excuse in a long line of excuses why the movie failed at the box office. It was bad reviews and poor word of mouth that killed “IWTB” not The Dark Knight. The X-Files franchise needs a fresh start and wipe the slate clean with a new cast and crew, and maybe get a A-list director and writer attached to the movie to get a whole new generation of people interested in the X-Files again. The only people that don’t like the idea of a reboot are the hardcore fans that David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson are the only actors to play Mulder and Scully, but hollywood is a star driven business and Duchovny and Anderson don’t have any box office clout, but if they cast the movie right I’m sure the fans will get over it. But in the end it’s all up to FOX if they want another X-Files movie or not. Sorry for the long rant.

  • http://www.x-fileslexicon.com/ Matt

    I too have to disagree with Brunoman17. One of the major problems with IWTB was, it was a difficult film that should have been released in the fall of 2008. It was also hampered by people’s assumptions that it was going to directly deal with aliens, while many seasonal episodes were stand alone’s that didn’t deal with the mythology. When the public could not deal with their superficial assumptions, then it didn’t do well.

    While there are countless examples of lousy films per year, it’s difficult to qualify something as ‘bad’ simply because it’s not easy to digest on a first viewing. As far as the ‘lack of chemistry’ you speak of, that wasn’t the film that I saw. Lastly, while many sing the praises of “Fringe”, while I hold nothing against those that enjoy the show, to each his own, I still maintain that “Fringe” is a hollow imitation of “The X-Files”, that I just can’t get behind personally. Such shows as “Fringe, Supernatural, Lost, Warehouse 13,” etc… Would not exist, if not for Chris Carter, and Frank Spotnitz.

    Since we are getting into a reality check, Glen Morgan and James Wong’s feature film track record has been spotty, at best, in my opinion, as much as I like them, and they’ve done some great work, it has to be said.

  • http://www.popcornmonster.com Dan Geer

    brunoman17,

    I’ll have to respectively agree to disagree. Regardless of what you think,X-Files still has a huge fanbase that rather enjoyed Fight the Future quite a bit (myself included), and there are even quite a lot of people that that loved I Want to Believe (the film grew on me). There are also people discovering the series for the first time (especially those who were too young when it was still on the air) and becoming fans. Many film sites (both X-Files related and general movie sites) have stated that, regardless of how good or bad they thought IWTB was, they would welcome a third film if the story is good and true to the alien mythology storyline – which is exactly what Carter plans on doing. Heck, even Perez Hilton wants a third movie!

    I blame the poor box office tally of IWTB not on Carter, Spotnitz, Duchovny or Anderson – but rather on The Dark Knight, which came out only one week prior, as well as the poor promotion of IWTB. Even if you think IWTB was horrible, it most likely would have done better in its opening weekend had it been promoted better and released a month or two later when not much else was coming out. Summer 2008 was the summer of The Dark Knight, and most every other movie released within a couple weeks of that film underperformed at the box office. Everyone was going to see TDK again and again. It was a great film, and it was Heath Ledger’s performance of a lifetime. Who could blame them? Good or bad, IWTB, as well as other films, didn’t stand a chance coming out so soon after TDK . With IWTB, it had nothing to do with it being an X-Files film.

    Now, I won’t deny that many who did see IWTB didn’t like it. But I think more people would’ve gone to see it in its first weekend if it was released a month or two later. If a third film happens, and it’s what people want this time around (alien mythology), I think it could do quite well. Maybe not like The Dark Knight, but I think it could end up bringing in much more more than IWTB did if it gets released and promoted at the right time.

    Also, regarding not having Duchovny and Anderson, they are the bread and butter of that franchise. No one who likes X-Files would want to see other actors fill those shoes. Frankly, I think they have aged quite well, especially Anderson (she looks better now than 20 years ago!). And, as far as Carter and Spotnitz not returning, anything X-Files will have to have Carter’s approval – especially if XF3 is to indeed be about the alien mythology storyline. As a fan, I would not want to see anyone else behind the story except Carter and Spotnitz. Carter knows where he intended the mythology to go, and that’s what I want to see. I’m okay with having someone else direct, since I thought Rob Bowman did a wonderful job with Fight the Future. But really only Carter and, to an extent Spotnitz, know how it all should end.

    I do think Duchovny is a bit out of his mind regarding releasing an X-Files film in the summer, especially since IWTB did so poorly last time around and many other bigger films (including the next Batman film) are coming out then. But I really don’t think an X-Files film with him, Anderson, Carter and Spotnitz is destined to fail. They are the only ones who will do it right. And FOX Chairman Tom Rothman said he’s fine with FOX distributing a third film as long as Carter, Duchovny and Anderson are on board – which they are.

  • brunoman17

    David Duchovny is delusional. A X-files movie with Duchovny, Anderson, and Carter is going to fail, no matter what time of the year is released. No way FOX is going to approve a big budget X-File movie with two aging TV actors who has no box office appeal and their on screen chemistry was long dead and only worked for television not on the big screen. The only way the X-files can fight with the big boys is to get rid of Chris Carter and Frank Spotnitz and get a new writer and director to take over the franchise. I know that sounds harsh, but the truth (while also being out there) hurts.

  • Steffi

    I absolutely agree that fall would be the best time for release. Thinking about the “big” movies people going to watch just for entertaining. If we think about the plot and the story should take place in Dec 2010 why showing this movie in summer again????
    In summer I don’t want to watch a “winter-movie” or a story taking place around christmas :-) So, let’s see what will happen.

  • http://www.popcornmonster.com Dan Geer

    This website is intended to be a blog (albeit, one that reports accurate info), not the New York Times. It was also put in quotes which, I believe, is what you do when you use slang terms in an article. I could be wrong, which is why this is a blog.

    And by the way, I believe I read the term “fanboy” in USA Today once. :)

  • JonLaw

    Wow, what a horribly written article. Anyone who uses the word Fanboy in modern English is clearly not a journalist.

    Thanks for wasting 30 seconds of my life.

  • http://www.popcornmonster.com Dan Geer

    Just thought I’d add to my own post and list off some of the major movies X-Files would be up against in Summer 2012:

    1) Star Trek 2
    2) Men in Black 3
    3) The Dark Knight Rises
    4) The Avengers
    5) Spider-Man reboot
    etc. etc. etc.

    Winter isn’t good either, as Superman: Man of Steel and The Hobbit: Part I are in December.

    Late, late summer or early fall, I say. Or, even late Spring – like April 2012 if they can get it made by then.

Recent Posts: